The short version: Muslim women did not start veiling at a single moment, and veiling did not start with Islam. The practice was already a sign of status in the societies Islam emerged among and conquered. The Qur’an addresses women’s dress in a few verses; the detailed rules were the work of later jurists; and the headscarf most people now call “the hijab” is, in its present form and meaning, largely a development of the 1970s (Islam §11). Majority
The word ḥijāb
In the Qur’an, ḥijāb does not mean a garment. It means a screen or curtain, and the verse that uses it in this sense concerns the Prophet’s household:
wa-idhā saʾaltumūhunna matāʿan fa-sʾalūhunna min warāʾi ḥijāb
“When you ask his wives for something, do so from behind a screen.” (Q 33:53, trans. Abdel Haleem)[1][2]
The word came to mean a woman’s head covering only later, and in modern English it is used above all for the headscarf. Majority
What the Qur’an says about dress
Two verses address women’s clothing directly. One tells believing women to guard their modesty and to draw their head-coverings (khumur, singular khimār) over their necklines:
wa-l-yaḍribna bi-khumurihinna ʿalā juyūbihinna
“They should let their headscarves fall to cover their necklines.” (Q 24:31)[3]
The other tells the Prophet’s wives, daughters and the believing women to draw their outer garments (jalābīb) close around them, “so as to be recognized and not insulted”:
yudnīna ʿalayhinna min jalābībihinna
“To make their outer garments hang low over them.” (Q 33:59)[4]
Consensus on what the verses say. They do not specify which parts of the body must be covered, and the first presupposes that women already wore a head-covering, telling them how to wear it. What exactly the verses require has been debated by Muslim scholars from the beginning, and still is. Contested
Veiling before Islam
The verses addressed a society in which head coverings were already worn. Leila Ahmed, in Women and Gender in Islam (1992), traced veiling and seclusion as marks of rank across the ancient Near East: an Assyrian law code laid down which women must veil and which, such as enslaved women and prostitutes, must not; and in the Byzantine and Sasanian empires that the Arabs conquered, veiling marked women of the upper classes.[5] Majority Ahmed argued that Muslims adopted much of the later practice from these conquered societies rather than from the Qur’an alone.[5] Majority Reza Aslan similarly argues that the veil “was neither compulsory nor widely adopted until generations after Muhammad’s death”.[6] Contested on how quickly it spread.
From verse to law
The law of dress, like most of Islamic law, was worked out by the jurists of the eighth to tenth centuries, who turned the Qur’an and the hadith into rules (Islam §6). The four Sunni schools came to require a free woman to cover everything except her face and hands in front of men outside her family, with differences between and within the schools over the face, the hands and the feet. Majority In practice dress varied by class, region and period: the face veil and the enveloping outer garment marked urban women of status, while rural and working women dressed differently. Majority
The great unveiling, 1920s–1950s
Between the 1920s and the 1950s many urban, educated women across the Middle East abandoned the face veil and often the head covering, sometimes by choice and sometimes under compulsion.[5] Consensus
- Egypt, by choice. In 1923 Hudā Shaʿrāwī, returning from an international women’s suffrage congress in Rome, removed her face veil on the platform of Cairo railway station; the women who met her applauded, and some did the same. She founded the Egyptian Feminist Union that year.[5] Consensus
- Iran, by force. On 8 January 1936 Reza Shah banned the veil: police were ordered to remove the chador and headscarf from women in public, and many women stayed at home rather than go out unveiled. The ban lapsed when he abdicated in 1941.[7] Consensus Houchang Chehabi argues that the coercion made the veil, for many Iranians, a symbol of resistance to the state.[7] Majority
- Turkey, by campaign. The republic changed men’s dress by law and discouraged the veil by example and campaign. Majority A 1982 regulation required female civil servants to work bareheaded, and the ban was extended to universities; it was eased in universities from 2008, lifted in most government posts in October 2013 and in schools in 2014. Consensus
Ahmed argued that the colonial argument for unveiling, which linked women’s liberation to adopting European dress, had made the veil a symbol of cultural resistance long before it became a symbol of piety again.[5] Majority
The new veiling, from the 1970s
From the 1970s a new style of covering, the headscarf with modest, long dress, spread among university students and professional women in Egypt, closely linked to the Islamic revival, and from there to much of the Muslim world and its diasporas.[8] Majority This is the garment most people now call “the hijab”. It was new in style. In A Quiet Revolution (2011), Ahmed, who grew up in an unveiled Cairo, traced that return and found that for many women in the United States the veil had come to mean activism and identity rather than subordination.[8] Majority
Compulsion and prohibition today
Since 1979 states have both required and forbidden it.
- Iran. In March 1979 Khomeini said women should observe Islamic dress; thousands of women protested from 8 March, International Women’s Day, and the order was briefly withdrawn. From July 1980 unveiled women were refused entry to government offices and workplaces, and a law of 1983 made improper veiling punishable by flogging.[9] Consensus See Islam §12 for the revolution.
- Afghanistan. The Taliban, in power from 1996, enforced dress rules through a religious police (Islam §12).[10] Consensus
- France. A law of 15 March 2004 banned conspicuous religious signs in state schools, widely understood as aimed at the headscarf; a law of 2010 banned face coverings in public places, upheld by the European Court of Human Rights in 2014 (Islam §13).[11][12][13] Consensus on the laws.
Supporters of each kind of law present it as protecting religion, secularism or women; opponents present it as coercion. Political
Debates
Does the Qur’an require women to cover their hair?
Most classical and modern jurists hold that it does, reading khimār as a head covering. Some modern Muslim scholars and reformers argue that the verses require modesty, not a particular garment. Contested
What did the veil’s return mean?
A symbol imposed by Islamist movements, a chosen identity, or both in different places: Ahmed’s two books chart her own change of view.[5][8] Contested; Political
Common misconceptions
- “The Qur’an uses the word hijab for women’s clothing.” It uses it for a screen; its words for garments are khimār and jilbāb. Consensus
- “Veiling began with Islam.” It was already a mark of status in the ancient Near East and in the empires Islam conquered.[5] Majority
- “Muslim women have always worn the headscarf in the same way.” Practice varied by class, region and century; many urban women went unveiled for much of the twentieth century, and today’s headscarf is a modern style. Consensus
References
- ^ Qur'an 33:53 — The Qur'an. early 7th c. CE. Arabic. Visitors should ask the Prophet's wives for things from behind a screen (ḥijāb). about
- ^ M. A. S. Abdel Haleem The Qur'an: A New Translation. Oxford University Press (Oxford World's Classics), 2004. The translation quoted in the Islam series unless stated.
- ^ Qur'an 24:31 — The Qur'an. early 7th c. CE. Arabic. Believing women should guard their modesty and draw their head-coverings (khumur) over their necklines. about
- ^ Qur'an 33:59 — The Qur'an. early 7th c. CE. Arabic. The Prophet's wives, daughters and believing women should draw their outer garments (jalābīb) close, to be recognised and not insulted. about
- ^ a b c d e f g Leila Ahmed Women and Gender in Islam: Historical Roots of a Modern Debate. Yale University Press, 1992. Women's history in the Middle East and the colonial politics of the veil.
- ^ Reza Aslan No god but God: The Origins, Evolution, and Future of Islam. Random House, 2005. A popular history; argues that the veil spread generations after Muhammad.
- ^ a b H. E. Chehabi The Banning of the Veil and Its Consequences. in Stephanie Cronin (ed.), The Making of Modern Iran (Routledge), 2003. Reza Shah's 1936 unveiling and its enforcement and legacy.
- ^ a b c Leila Ahmed A Quiet Revolution: The Veil's Resurgence, from the Middle East to America. Yale University Press, 2011. The return of veiling from 1970s Egypt to the United States.
- ^ Lois Beck and Guity Nashat, eds. Women in Iran from 1800 to the Islamic Republic. University of Illinois Press, 2004. Essays on Iranian women's history, including the imposition of compulsory veiling after 1979.
- ^ Ahmed Rashid Taliban: Militant Islam, Oil and Fundamentalism in Central Asia. Yale University Press, 2000. The Taliban's rise from the Pakistani madrasas to the capture of Kabul.
- ^ Loi n° 2004-228 du 15 mars 2004 (Code de l'éducation, art. L141-5-1) — French law on religious symbols in schools. 15 March 2004. French. Bans signs or dress by which pupils conspicuously show a religious affiliation in public schools. about
- ^ Loi n° 2010-1192 du 11 octobre 2010 interdisant la dissimulation du visage dans l'espace public — French face-covering law. 11 October 2010. French. "No one may, in public space, wear clothing designed to conceal the face"; in force 11 April 2011. about
- ^ S.A.S. v. France (ECtHR, 1 July 2014) and UN Human Rights Committee views (October 2018) — Rulings on the French face-covering ban. 2014–2018. English and French. The European Court upholds the ban on grounds of "living together"; the UN Human Rights Committee finds it disproportionately harmed two women's right to manifest their religion. about